Hello,
I have a Banana Pi BPI-R4 Pro 8X board and I am experiencing a consistent issue where outgoing (TX) traffic from the MT7988A SoC (gmac2 / 10GBASE-R) to the MaxLinear MxL86252 switch never reaches the physical ports (lan1–lan4 and 10G-LAN), while incoming (RX) traffic and intra-switch L2 forwarding work fine.
Key symptoms & tests performed:
- Reproduced on stock factory OpenWrt (SPI-NAND) as well as custom Linux 7.3 (based on
frank-w/BPI-Router-Linux7.3-main):lan5(connected to the internal MT7530 switch) works completely fine (both RX and TX).10G-WAN(eth1/ AS21010PB1 PHY) links up and passes traffic on the stock image.lan1–lan4(MxL86252 switch): physical link comes up (1Gbps/Fullor2.5Gbps/Full), LEDs work, and RX packets from connected clients reach the SoC (verified viatcpdumponeth2/end2,lan2,br0, and ARP/FDB tables populate).- However, zero TX packets leave the physical RJ45 ports of MxL86252.
- Switch-to-switch L2 test:
- Connecting two devices directly to
lan1andlan2passes L2 traffic between them without any issues — so the GPHYs and physical RJ45 jacks on the MxL86252 are working.
- Connecting two devices directly to
- Loopback patch-cord test (
lan2↔lan3):- When connecting
lan2andlan3with a patch cord and sending ARP/ICMP out oflan2,tcpdumponlan2shows the outgoing frames,end2TX counters increment, and MxL86252 RMONtx_packetscounter increments, buttcpdumponlan3receives nothing (even though RX fromlan3to SoC works).
- When connecting
- Switch firmware & tagging checks:
- Initially the switch had factory firmware
1.0.70 (build 70)— same exact behavior (RX works, TX fails). - Updated the MxL86252 firmware via
fwupd(LVFS) to official1.0.85 (build 85)(GPHY 0.105) — the issue persists identically on both stock OpenWrt and Linux 7.3 (tested with bothmxl862xx-8021qand nativemxl862xxtag protocols, with and without bridge, and with HW offloads disabled).
- Initially the switch had factory firmware
Relevant dmesg snippet:
mtk_soc_eth 15100000.ethernet end2: configuring for fixed/10gbase-r link mode
mtk_soc_eth 15100000.ethernet end2: Link is Up - 10Gbps/Full - flow control rx/tx
mxl862xx mdio-bus:10: switch ready after 2652ms, firmware 1.0.85 (build 85)
mxl862xx mdio-bus:10: configuring for fixed/10gbase-r link mode
mxl862xx mdio-bus:10: Link is Up - 10Gbps/Full - flow control off
Could this be a hardware defect on the 10GBASE-R TX differential pair (GMAC2_TXP/N / AC-coupling capacitors) between MT7988A and MxL86252 on my specific board, or is there any known SerDes/XPCS/pin-strap configuration issue on the BPI-R4 Pro 8X revision?
Thanks in advance for any help!